In the last decade, the UK contracting sector has been reshaped by sweeping legislative reforms, with no signs of slowing. From IR35 changes to Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) compliance crackdowns, and now increasing scrutiny of umbrella companies, contractors, employers, and recruitment agencies alike, contractors are navigating one of the most turbulent periods in the industry’s history.

IR35 & the Off-Payroll Working Rules: A Sector Still in Recovery

The 2017 and 2021 IR35 reforms shifted the responsibility for determining employment status from contractors to end-clients in the public and private sectors. While designed to close tax loopholes, these changes have had far-reaching consequences:

• Limited company contracting has plummeted, with tens of thousands fewer PSCs (Personal Service Companies) formed since the reforms.
• Risk-averse clients have issued blanket bans on limited company contractors, reducing truly ‘outside IR35’ roles.
• Freelancers have exited the sector, citing lost autonomy, rising compliance risks, and a loss of control over how they work.

HMRC, meanwhile, continues to intensify enforcement, launching more IR35 investigations, demanding robust evidence of genuine self-employment, and pushing for widespread adoption of its controversial CEST tool, which remains problematic and inconsistent.

Construction Firms on Alert

Simultaneously, the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) has come under renewed scrutiny. HMRC is particularly focused on:

• Deemed contractor rules and the £3m threshold, aiming to tackle perceived abuses.
• Verification issues in the subcontractor system, causing disruption and compliance concerns.
• Greater enforcement through new technology, dedicated investigation teams, and higher penalties for non-compliance.

Construction businesses must now treat CIS compliance as a priority, especially as HMRC increases its use of real-time data tools to flag inconsistencies and fraud.

The Rise (and Risks) of Umbrella Companies

With limited companies increasingly shut out of the market, many contractors have found themselves forced into umbrella company arrangements. Nearly 30% of contractors now operate via umbrellas, but this has raised several concerns:

• Contractors are often treated like employees, without the career benefits, development opportunities, or job security.
• Umbrella companies typically serve a transactional purpose, handling payroll and deductions in exchange for a fee, but without a meaningful employer-employee relationship.
• Non-compliant umbrellas have flourished, often linked to tax avoidance schemes or questionable deductions.

Government attention has now turned to reforming this sector, including plans to shift PAYE liability from umbrella companies to recruitment agencies — a move that may radically reshape or even eliminate umbrellas altogether.

Mounting HMRC Pressure: More Investigations, More Penalties

Across the board, HMRC is stepping up efforts to identify non-compliance, deliberate fraud, and tax avoidance. This includes:

• Greater use of digital investigation tools and court action.
• Aggressive pursuit of penalties and interest on backdated tax.
• An increasing focus on deliberate non-compliance, even where rules remain unclear or subjective.

For contractors, this means more than ever, compliance is critical.

Recommendations: How Contractors Can Protect Themselves

In light of these changes, here’s what contractors — and those engaging them — should do:

• Review your IR35 status regularly, ensuring your contract and working practices align.
• Keep clear records of expenses, contracts, and communications.
• Seek specialist tax and legal advice, especially if operating via a PSC.
• Ensure to protect your family and your day rate with Business Protection insurance.
• Consider IR35 insurance to help cover legal costs in the event of an HMRC investigation.
• Stay informed about upcoming reforms, particularly those affecting umbrella company oversight and PAYE responsibilities.

A Sector at a Crossroads

UK contracting is undergoing a fundamental transformation. The combination of stricter IR35 enforcement, renewed CIS focus, and looming umbrella reform is reshaping how freelancers work, how clients engage talent, and how agencies manage risk.

Unfortunately, these policy changes have not always been coherent or contractor-friendly, and the burden often falls hardest on genuine self-employed professionals who simply want to deliver great work on fair terms. At a time when the UK economy needs flexible talent more than ever, it’s vital that policymakers recognise the value of contractors, freelancers, and consultants, and work toward creating a stable, sustainable, and fair environment for all.

Speak to an expert